Jerry's Pizza Mill

Discover Jerry's Pizza Mill in Waialua, HI, where you can enjoy delicious pizza, subs, and live music. Try our signature pineapple pizza, meatball sub, and dessert pizza, along with pinball fun and garlic fries. Call +1 808-637-8866 today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Jerry's Pizza Mill

Taste the Difference.

Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill

Jerry's Pizza Mill welcomes everyone to experience a slice of the good life in Waialua, Hawaii. Located conveniently on Goodale Ave, this pizza haven is not just a restaurant; it’s a community gathering spot where laughter mingles with the delicious aroma of fresh pizzas. People flock here not only for the standout dishes like the famous meatball sub and unique dessert pizzas but also for the vibrant atmosphere filled with retro pinball machines and lively music.

Grab a seat and dig into a pineapple pizza or a hearty Philly cheese steak, the culinary icons served with a Hawaiian twist. Whether stopping by for lunch or dinner, expect to enjoy hearty meals and a warm community vibe. There’s always something happening at Jerry's, making it the perfect local hangout.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

67-292 Goodale Ave, Waialua, HI 96791, United States

Phone

+1 808-637-8866

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill
Jerry's Pizza Mill

Jerry's Pizza Mill prides itself on creating a unique dining experience in Waialua. Its menu is a balance of flavors, delivering quality and variety that appeals to both locals and visitors. Pizza lovers can indulge in options like the 'Waialua' specialty pizza and the 'BBQ Chicken,' while traditionalists can savor the classic flavors of garlic fries or chicken wings. Each dish reflects a commitment to fresh ingredients and bold flavors, which keeps the model of Hawaiian comfort food thriving.

The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner, with the lunchtime rush hitting hardest on Mondays.

Whether you're catching a bite between adventures or winding down after a long day, Jerry's serves as the perfect spot to recharge. Families and friends often gather here, making it a common place for celebrations, game days, or just casual evening meals. The casual vibe welcomes everyone who wants to escape the hustle and enjoy a hearty meal.

Community engagement sets Jerry's apart from traditional pizza joints as it often collaborates with local musicians, showcasing talent while patrons dine. This commitment to supporting local culture fosters a sense of belonging that touches the heart of Waialua. Overall, Jerry's Pizza Mill is more than just a place to eat; it’s a place to connect.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Jerry's Pizza Mill stands out with multiple unique features that enhance the dining experience. The restaurant hosts several classic pinball machines, adding a nostalgic touch and fun for all ages. The menu boasts an impressive selection of plates, including 11 varieties of pizzas, 5 types of delicious subs, and several handcrafted sides and desserts. Vegetarian? There’s a specialty veggie pizza just for you. Craving something sweet? The dessert pizzas, like banana cinnamon and strawberry chocolate, promise to delight. Live music often fills the air, creating an inviting backdrop as guests dine with friends and family. The vibrant decor and friendly service ensure that every visit is memorable.

Jerry's Pizza Mill

The exterior of Jerry's Pizza Mill exudes a casual warmth that invites passersby to come on in. Bright signage and colorful decor hint at the delicious meals awaiting inside. The outdoor seating options allow guests to enjoy the famous Hawaiian sunshine while savoring their favorite meals.

This inviting atmosphere turns any meal into a relaxed gathering of friends and family, adding to the sense of community that Jerry's fosters. Weekends often see lively crowds, accentuated by laughter and the sounds of the pinball machines chiming away.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

GO JERRY!!!! great pizza they let us do half and half and it was amazing!!!! It's a lil place but with lots of heart we ordered half waiamea and half arugula 16" Salads are insane too!

C
Carlos P.

After days of only 4 radio channels, Jerry's music selections were a tangible relief. The pizza was great, and we visited on a Sunday so things were quiet and calm. Highly recommend after a visit to the distillery!

M
Molly W.

Outstanding experience. This may be the best pizza I've ever had. Ingredients were delicious, dough tasted hand made, and the staff was having fun with their work. Music was playing, staff was joking around with each other, and our server, Ian, was attentive, answered questions, brought us water and made basically a custom pizza for us. I bought a shirt and Ian made sure I tried it on before I bought it because he knew the sizes could be a little off. They bring that level of attention to detail to the food as well. Just top notch pizza. Very highly recommend this place if you've just caught a fall sunset on the north shore. Cute little romantic booths too!

C
Caleb H.

Amazing classic sub and pizza!! Angela and Jill are great and super friendly. Great experience! I placed a phone order and it was ready when I arrived. They also knead their own dough!!

N
Nico V.

We came to this place because of another review by Tom who mentioned this has the best pizza on island and it did not disappoint. The customer service was absolutely excellent and we loved that you were able to do half and half pizzas on the 16" size. The pizza was delicious and affordable and was a great stop for lunch. In the photo we got half Arugula and half Margarita.

P
Parker W.

We ordered just a plain cheese pizza to go a couple nights ago and it was sooo cheesy and fresh and yummy! We will definitely be back. Thank you so much!

S
S R.